male manager discussing with male employee

Conduct vs Capability

Employee Performance

24 Oct 2023 (Last updated 30 June 2025)

Share on:

Conduct at work is a separate issue to that of capability. It can be difficult to differentiate between the two. Employers must establish whether the employee is falling short of standards because of their capability or conduct before proceeding with formal action.

Capability is when an employee is unable to achieve the expected standards of performance due to a lack of skill, ability, or training. Conduct relates to a person’s behaviour at work not reaching the required standards.

The key difference is the level of control the employee has over the situation. When it relates to capability, the employee may be trying as hard as they can but simply cannot reach the expected standards. However, with regard to conduct issues, the employee could perform better but for whatever reason is choosing not to do so.

Understanding conduct

Some of the behaviours that may indicate poor conduct at work may include: theft, drinking or drug abuse at work, abusive behaviour, leaking confidential documents or information, misuse of computers, lack of punctuality, poor presentation, unauthorised absence, inappropriate conduct with other members of staff during office hours or outside work hours that impacts on the employee’s job.

Understanding capability

If there is a gap between the employee’s performance and the standards expected, then this is defined as a capability issue. Such issues should be drawn to the employee’s attention at an early stage and expected improvements, with measurable targets, should be laid out. The employee should feel both supported in improving their work performance and also understand the potential consequences if improvement is not attained with a certain time.

As an employer, it is important to ensure that there is a consistent approach to the management of capability at work. The main aim with regard to capability issues is to ensure that, wherever possible, standards of work are reaching the performance levels required of the employee. All concerns about capability should be logged on personnel records and communicated to the employee as soon as possible.

Capability should be assessed by measuring the employee’s skills, abilities and performance against clear standards and expectations. These expected standards of performance should have been communicated to the employee from the outset of their employment and be consistent with expectations of all employees in the same role. It may be that the employee needs extra support such as training in order to achieve the expected standards of work.

Get complete HR support with Peninsula

As Australia’s leading workplace relations specialist, we can assist you with understanding or managing poor conduct or poor capability of employees in your workplace. Contact Peninsula today to speak with our team members.

Related Blog Articles

Employee Performance

The Importance of Work Ethic

In today’s competitive work environment, possessing a strong work ethic is more than a desirable attribute. It is a fundamental component of professional success. But what precisely does ‘work ethic’ entail, and why is it so crucial?   This blog delves into the meaning of work ethic, its significance, and the top skills that exemplify a robust ethical framework in the workplace.  What is work ethic?   Work ethic is a set of values, beliefs, and principles that guide an individual's approach to work. It encompasses an internal compass that influences their attitude, behaviour, and decision. A strong work ethic means being dedicated to your job or duties, displaying a level of discipline, and demonstrating a commitment to achieving goals.  Benefits for employees Drives professional growth  Consistent hard work and commitment often lead to recognition, opportunities for advancement, long-term success, and potential for higher earnings. A strong work ethic can make you a more attractive candidate for promotions and new roles, leading to a more successful career.  Contributes to job satisfaction Multiple studies have shown a strong work ethic can foster a sense of accomplishment and personal satisfaction, knowing you've dedicated effort and achieved results. This builds self-confidence and a belief in your ability to overcome challenges.  Improved personal skills Working hard often necessitates developing time management, problem-solving and communication skills. These skills are valuable in both your professional and personal life.  Greater resilience Facing challenges and overcoming obstacles through a strong work ethic builds resilience and the ability to bounce back from setbacks. These mental characteristics can benefit you in all aspects of life.  Benefits for businesses  Increased productivity Individuals with a strong work ethic are often more productive, as they are self-motivated and diligent, and complete tasks efficiently. They’re also more likely to produce high-quality work.  Enhanced innovation and creativity Numerous studies have also shown that a strong work ethic often cultivates a culture of innovation. Continuous improvement and creative thinking can lead to a more competitive edge for your organisation.  Improved customer satisfaction Employees with a solid work ethic are more likely to go the extra mile for customers, leading to higher satisfaction and loyalty. This can translate to increased revenue and profitability for the organisation.  Reduced costs In contrast to those with a poor work ethic, a strong work ethic can lead to lower absenteeism, staff turnover and counterproductive work behaviours, reducing operational costs for businesses.   Positive work culture When employees value hard work and commitment, it creates a more positive overall company culture, benefiting everyone within the business.  Top skills that showcase a strong work ethic  A range of skills, traits and behaviours characterises a strong work ethic. Here are some relevant examples.   Reliability: Being dependable and reliable, showing up on time and meeting deadlines are hallmarks of a good work ethic.  2.Professionalism: Exhibiting professionalism through respectful behaviour, dressing appropriately, and maintaining a positive demeanour reflects well on one's work ethic.  Initiative: Going above and beyond, seeking new challenges and being proactive demonstrate a readiness to contribute and a desire to succeed.  Persistence: The willingness to persevere through challenges without giving up is a testament to a strong work ethic.  Takes Responsibility: Taking ownership of one's duties and being accountable for outcomes, whether good or bad, shows a mature approach to work.  Time management: Efficiently managing one’s time to prioritise tasks and consistently meet deadlines is crucial for demonstrating a strong work ethic.  Teamwork: Collaborating effectively with others, being a good listener, and contributing to team goals are indicative of a person who values their work and their colleagues.  Ethical behaviour: Upholding ethical standards, honesty, and integrity in all professional dealings is fundamental to a strong work ethic.  Work ethic across career stages  Strong work ethics manifest in diverse ways across different career stages.  New entrants Initiative: Stepping outside comfort zones, proposing new ideas and taking ownership of tasks demonstrate proactiveness and a willingness to learn.  Growth mindset: Embracing feedback, seeking mentorship, and actively pursuing learning opportunities like training programs, certifications and networking events showcase a commitment to continuous improvement.  Adaptability: Navigating a new environment, learning company norms, and adjusting to changing demands require flexibility and a willingness to evolve.  Cultural considerations: Recognising and respecting diverse work styles and communication preferences across generations and backgrounds fosters a sense of belonging and inclusivity.  Mid-career professionals Leadership: Taking ownership of projects, guiding, and motivating teams and fostering collaboration demonstrate leadership skills and commitment to collective success.  Mentorship: Sharing knowledge, providing guidance, and advocating for junior colleagues showcases a commitment to nurturing the next generation.  Work-life balance: Successfully managing professional and personal obligations while maintaining high performance reflects maturity and responsibility.  Negotiation and advocacy: Articulating value, negotiating compensation and benefits, and advocating for personal and professional development opportunities demonstrate assertiveness and self-awareness.  Senior executives Strategic decision-making: Making sound judgment calls based on data, analysis and consideration of diverse perspectives contributes to sustainable organisational growth.  Vision and mission alignment: Inspiring and motivating teams by effectively communicating the organisation's vision, mission and values fosters clarity and purpose.  Ethical leadership: Setting the tone for ethical conduct, promoting transparency, and building trust with stakeholders demonstrates integrity and commitment to responsible business practices.  Building a culture of innovation: Encouraging creative thinking, risk-taking, and experimentation within ethical boundaries drives innovation and adaptability.  Balancing work ethic with well-being  While advocating for strong work ethics, it's crucial to recognise the risk of burnout. The pursuit of excellence must be balanced with self-care and setting boundaries. Relentless dedication without prioritising rest, hobbies and social connections can impact well-being,productivity and creativity.  How to build strong work ethic in your business   So, how do you cultivate a strong work ethic in your company culture without resorting to pressure tactics or burnout? Here are some effective strategies to build and improve work ethic.   Lead by example  Be the embodiment of the work ethic you desire. Arrive on time, stay focused, and tackle challenges with enthusiasm.  Empowerment, not micromanagement Trust your employees. Give them ownership of their tasks, provide clear expectations, and offer support without hovering. This fosters a sense of responsibility, trust, and motivates them to excel.  Meaningful recognition  Don't underestimate the power of a simple ‘thank you’ or public recognition. Celebrate individual and team achievements to show appreciation and reinforce desired behaviours.  Invest in growth Offer opportunities for professional development, like workshops, conferences, or online courses. Equipping your team with new skills keeps them engaged and boosts their confidence and performance. When you invest in your team, they’ll invest in your business.  Work-life balance matters Respect personal time and encourage breaks. Promote healthy habits and flexible work arrangements that show you care about their well-being. Happy and balanced employees are more productive and dedicated.  Open communication Communicate effectively, encourage honest feedback, and create a safe space for employees to voice concerns. Proactively addressing issues fosters trust and shows you value their input.  Shared goals and vision Clearly communicate the company's mission and goals and ensure each employee understands their role in achieving them. This collective purpose fosters a sense of ownership and motivates individuals to go the extra mile.  Reward systems Consider implementing incentive programs aligned with your desired work ethic behaviours. However, focus on intrinsic rewards like recognition and growth opportunities alongside any financial incentives.  Unlock your potential with Peninsula If you want to develop a stronger work ethic or cultivate these skills within your team, consider reaching out for professional guidance. Our HR experts offer resources and training to help individuals and organisations achieve their full potential through the power of a strong work ethic. Contact today to learn how we can help your business.

Employee Performance

How to Conduct Performance Appraisals

Employee performance reviews or performance appraisals can be useful in improving your overall performance. If done right, employees and supervisors or managers are able to share expectations and collaborate to achieve results. This can lead to increased employee engagement, reduced levels of employee dissatisfaction, performance improvement, increased motivation and morale.   What is a performance appraisal? A performance appraisal is an evaluation of an employee’s job performance and contribution to the company. The performance appraisal process evaluates an employee’s achievements, skills, and growth or lack thereof in terms of company and employee goals and objectives. Performance appraisals are primarily used by supervisors and managers to provide feedback to each employee regarding their performance and serve as a basis for changing behaviour towards more effective working habits. Steps to conducting a performance appraisal  Conducting employee performance appraisals can seem like a straightforward process, but sometimes even the most experienced and competent HR practitioners, managers, and supervisors may struggle to conduct effective performance review processes. Here are a few tips that may assist in the delivery of effective employee performance appraisals and review processes. 1. Preparation Adequate preparation assists in the likelihood of the processes succeeding.  Establish a purpose for the appraisal meeting beforehand. You can start by reviewing the notes from the employee’s previous appraisals and evaluate some of their more recent work to determine any patterns in the challenges they face. Prepare a list of points to discuss with the employee in the meeting and include potential solutions. Employee performance appraisals are two-way discussions. You may wish to create a joint agenda for the performance review meeting to guide the direction of the meeting and ensure you cover everything you intend to, highlighting both the employee’s struggles and successes. You may wish to give the employee time to prepare for the appraisal meeting beforehand. Communicate your meeting agenda and invite your employee to share their views and perhaps conduct a self-evaluation of their performance in preparation. Consider setting out the performance review process, their role in the evaluation process and what you’re looking for from them, and exactly how you’ll evaluate their performance against company objectives   2. Documentation Properly documenting what was discussed during a performance review may be useful for procedural and practical reasons. One way to do this is to use performance appraisal forms. They are an excellent way to assist with goal setting and tracking individual tasks and offer scope for employee self-evaluation; they should therefore form the basis of the performance appraisal meeting to help conduct objective and accurate evaluations of your employees. You may document your employee’s performance throughout the review period, such as missed deadlines or completed projects. You can also keep track of these developments through a performance appraisal form and ask your employee to do the same. This will allow you to have a comprehensive look at your employee’s performance. 3. Feedback Feedback from clients, as well as colleagues who’ve worked with the employee from their coworkers, boss, and any reporting staff can broaden the performance information to deliver to the employee. Consider using a structured format to make it easy to share the feedback with subordinates. Provide the employee with the feedback you’ve gathered before the meeting to allow them to digest the contents before discussing it with you at the appraisal meeting.  4. Evaluation  Evaluate employees based on goals and expectations that have been clearly set out and documented at the start of the review period or even at the start of their employment. Evaluating an employee’s performance against objectives or targets they were unaware of will make them feel blindsided. Also, keep in mind that the performance review meeting is a two-way discussion, and your employee should have input as well. Your employees are more likely to open up and be honest when they feel listened to and have a relationship of trust with their supervisor or manager. So let the employee speak first, then respond with constructive input. After every discussion point, summarise the conversation and check the consensus with regards to goal setting and understanding of future expectations.  While it’s easy to dwell on the negatives and what the employee should’ve done, try to focus on the positives. Discuss the employee’s successes and what worked, and how they can continue to grow. But this doesn’t mean you should sugarcoat negative reviews; instead, discuss practical ways they can improve. These critiques are meant to aid the employee, so be honest and work with them to find a way forward. Offer coaching on how an employee can improve on their weaknesses, and reward success and offer the employee development opportunities that correspond with their personal goals to keep them motivated. 5. Action Plan  To ensure your appraisals are effective, both the manager and the employee should come away from the performance review with a positive mindset and an action plan. Setting an action plan to help employees improve their skills should be a collaborative effort. Work with your employee to develop an action plan on what the employee can do to achieve their objectives and contribute towards the company’s goals. Employees that understand how their role fits into the overall operation of the business can work more effectively. You should consider the employee’s personal objectives and development opportunities and incorporate them into the action plan. Conclude the performance appraisal meeting by summarising what has been discussed, how and when the action plan will be implemented, and who is responsible for which tasks going forward. Monitor the employee’s progress, provide regular feedback and review the plan regularly to make sure it is still current.  Evaluate performance and do it regularly Consider having weekly, monthly, or quarterly review sessions. Regular reviews can help reduce some of the pressure that results from a yearly employee evaluation and provide a more pro-active approach to managing performance issues before they escalate. Weekly reviews can be informal to establish an open relationship between employee and their manager or supervisor. They should focus on the potential and development of the employee and incorporate practical steps for achieving employee and company objectives. If you incorporate these tips into your performance appraisal process, you may be able to  develop a more streamlined and effective review process. Performance reviews can significantly improve employee-manager communication and enhance your relationship with employees, as well as improve your organisation’s overall performance. Tailored HR and WHS for your business Peninsula offers customised HR and WHS solutions for businesses and employers. Our team supports businesses in understanding their obligations and keeping up with the constantly changing regulations. Talk to us today to learn how we can help you.

Employee Performance

The Benefits of Mentoring in the Workplace

Mentoring can benefit your employees and develop your business as it improves productivity.Mentoring is an efficient way for the mentor and mentee to develop new skills and navigate their careers. Let’s dive into mentoring, what it means, and how it can impact your business. Mentoring A mentor is a successful senior partner or leader who wishes to pass on their learnings and skills to someone they feel might benefit from their experience. Unlike management relationships, mentoring is voluntary on both sides and often unpaid. The notion of mentoring is very charitable. It stems from a desire to pass on skills to the next generation. Some organisations run formal mentoring programs and have paid mentorships with a defined goal. Mentorships are based on strong personal relationships and involve mutual respect, trust, and good communication. Becoming a good mentor can be crucial for your success if you are a business owner or employer. What are the ways to become a good mentor? Build a mentoring framework Establishing firm ground rules at the start of the mentorship can help you immensely. Being a mentor can often mean blurred boundaries and expectations. You ensure expectations are met by creating a framework and establishing ground rules. At the start of the mentorship, get together with your mentee and ask important questions like: Why do they believe they need a mentor? Why have they chosen you as their mentor? What is their goal? (can be time-based) What do they hope to achieve under your mentorship? Even if you know the answers to these questions, it’s better to have everything cleared up. Once these questions are answered, you can offer them a framework consisting of: The number of times you will be meeting The agenda of these meetings (set a time limit for each meeting) The ways they can communicate Contacting you in case of emergency The support you can offer The goal you have in mind Your expectation of the mentee Accountability The informality of mentorship can make it easy to forego accountability. Ensure that the mentee understands they are your student. They should be accountable and open to receiving constructive criticism. If mentees can’t take you seriously or respect authority, then it can be impossible to offer them your input or insights. You can hold your mentees accountable by: Getting them to commit to deadlines Ensuring they are open to constructive feedback and criticism Sticking to timelines and agendas Following up on tasks Avoiding repeating mistakes Conflict resolution Mentors must realise that conflict can happen between mentors and mentees. Keeping strategies in place for conflict resolution can help you in the long run. Having an honest discussion after every meeting can encourage the mentee to be honest about their needs Frame ‘Yes’ or ‘No’ questions to avoid ambiguity or misunderstandings (Are you happy/satisfied with your progress? Do you feel we need to do more?) Offer constructive feedback regularly so the mentee has clarity Do not let things escalate Choose mentees smartly Mentorship is not management. You cannot mentor multiple people at the same time. Being a mentor means putting away a significant chunk of your time to support someone’s career. Choose a mentee carefully and smartly. Look for traits and values that you believe make them worthy. Is the mentee willing to learn? Are they adaptable? Will the mentee do the hard work necessary to succeed? Consider doing a trial (like giving them an assignment or project) and evaluating them Observe them in other social and professional situations Understand mentoring power dynamics Remember that as a mentor, you are in a position of power. You must be conscious of acknowledging the power imbalance and not letting it become an obstacle.   What are the pitfalls of mentorships? Unable to accept the mentee’s point of view or opinion Unwilling to accept when you are wrong Taking their feedback personally Dominating them in meetings or professional settings Taking credit for their ideas Is mentorship for you? The idea of mentorship is appealing. It also has benefits such as: Improves leadership skills Improves communication skills Develops your repertoire Hones your interpersonal relationships Sharpens your mind Develops your focus When business owners or employers mentor others, they create strong and personal relationships that last. However, mentorship may not be for everybody. They are time-consuming and have no financial or immediate benefits. They can also go awry due to the lack of formal safeguards in place. Mentorship can also get tricky if you need to be focused on your career or business. It may not be the smart choice if your business needs your full attention. Like everything, you need to think carefully and make a pragmatic decision if you are ready to be a mentor. Grow with Peninsula Peninsula has worked with thousands of businesses across Australia and New Zealand. We understand how tricky it can get to manage employees and keep up with changing regulations. Our advisors are available 24/7 for business owners and their urgent questions. Chat with our team members to learn how we can help you.

Do you have any questions regarding Employee Performance?