cafe manager talking to employee

Shift penalties and overtime

Wage & Pay

15 May 2025 (Last updated 3 Sept 2025)

Share on:

Many businesses rely on shift workers to keep things running seamlessly 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Some roles that may involve shift work include customer service, hospitality, healthcare, and security.

What is shift work?

Shift work in Australia is defined as work outside of ‘ordinary hours of work as defined in an award, registered agreement, or employment contract.’

Depending upon the operations of the business, shifts may be arranged in any number of different ways. It is not uncommon to observe shifts being arranged as follows:

  • Morning shift.
  • Night shift.
  • Afternoon shift.
  • Weekend shift.

These schedules may be fixed (the employee is expected to work the same schedule each week) or variable (the employee is expected to work a rotating schedule of different shifts at different times of the day). They may also be required to be available to work upon request at any time of day (on-call).

The nature of the schedule – and what an award, agreement, or contract deems as ‘ordinary hours’ – may affect the type of penalties an employee receives, including annual leave loading.

Who are shift workers?

According to Australian legislation, under the Fair Work Act 2009, an employee is considered to be a shift worker if they:

  • Work for a business where shifts are rostered 24-hours a day, seven days a week
  • Are regularly rostered to work those shifts
  • Regularly work Sundays and public holidays
  • Employees defined as a ‘shiftworker’ in the applicable Modern Award or Enterprise Agreement

Shift workers have different annual leave entitlements than regular employees.

Shift penalties

Many awards and agreements in Australia provide shift workers with increased pay rates. The increased pay rates are referred to as shift penalties, penalty rates or shift loading.

Whether or not a penalty will be applied and how it will be applied depends on the modern award, enterprise agreement, or employment contract.

Some workplace arrangements may affect the payment of penalty rates.

Employees may be entitled to penalty rates when working particular hours or days. This can include:

  • Public holidays.
  • Weekends.
  • Overtime.
  • Early morning shifts.
  • Late night shifts.

Night shift penalty rates

Whether night shift workers are entitled to penalty rates depends on how a ‘night shift’ is defined in the award or agreement. Employers should refer to their respective award or registered agreement for clarity on night shift penalty rates. Some employees get paid a permanent night shift loading if they always work night shifts.

Allowances

An allowance is an extra payment made to employees who do certain tasks or use their own tools at work or work in hazardous conditions or incur an expense for doing their job.

Depending on the nature of the work, employers may also need to include allowances to reimburse shift workers for additional expenses incurred during their employment – such as meals, travel, and accommodation. Specific allowances or penalty rates depend on the award, agreement, or industrial instrument that applies.

Employees may be eligible for allowances in circumstances where they:

  • Use their own vehicle for work
  • Spend time travelling for work
  • Need to wear special clothing at work
  • Work in an environment that may damage their clothes or footwear

They might also be required to give shift workers additional breaks, which might be paid.

Overtime rates

Overtime refers to work performed outside of ordinary hours. The spread of ordinary hours should be reflected in the respective award, registered agreement, or employment contracts. The spread of ordinary hours is the times of the day the ordinary hours can be worked.

Overtime can include:

  • Work done beyond their maximum daily or weekly ordinary hours of work.
  • Outside a part-time employee’s agreed number of hours.
  • Outside the spread of ordinary hours.

As the rate of pay for overtime may differ depending on when it is worked, the applicable rate should also be specified.

Full-time employees are typically considered to be working overtime if they work beyond 38 hours for the week. While this is conventionally the understanding of ‘overtime’, there may still be variations depending on the nature of the job and modern award, which may specify the maximum ordinary hours an employee can work per day and times within which the employee can work those ordinary hours, in which case any time worked outside those hours may be payable as overtime.

You can only request or require your employees to work more than their maximum weekly hours where the additional hours are reasonable. Your employees can refuse any overtime that unreasonably exceeds maximum weekly hours. Please note that you also need to manage fatigue and other health and safety issues when requesting overtime.

Some agreements may allow employees to take paid time off instead of receiving overtime pay. This is commonly known as ‘time off in lieu.’ If employers opt for this approach, it needs to be established in writing with the employee’s consent and meet any award requirements.

Peninsula can help you understand shift penalties and overtime in your business and industry. Call 1300761935 for advice.

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute as business or legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. It does not take into consideration your specific business, industry or circumstances. You should seek legal or other professional advice regarding matters as they relate to you or your business. To the maximum extent permitted by law, Peninsula Group disclaim all liability for any errors or omissions contained in this information or any failure to update or correct this information. It is your responsibility to assess and verify the accuracy, completeness, and reliability of the information in this article.

Have a question?

Have a question that hasn't been answered? Fill in the form below and one of our experts will contact you back.

By clicking submit you consent to our Privacy Policy

Related Guide Articles

Wage & Pay

Commission

Commission work pays employees based on the number of products or services they sell in a given time period.  Commission pay is designed to motivate employees and reward outstanding performance especially in marketing and sales. Definition Commission pay can make up an employee’s whole wage or be paid as an extra incentive on top of their base wage or salary. How often an employee is paid commission depends on the terms of their employment agreement and the relevant Modern Award. An employee can only be paid exclusively on commission when an Award, Enterprise Agreement or other registered agreement states the employee can be paid this way. For information on commission-only payments, refer to the relevant award to understand how this type of payment works for employees. In some commission work (insurance for example) it’s common for salespeople to earn a residual commission (an ongoing series of payments) from clients who stay with the company and make repeat purchases. This is a powerful incentive for employees to stay with the company and saves money on recruitment costs. Sales Commission A sales based commission is an individual negotiation between the employee and the employer. As such, unless prescribed by an Award or Agreement, the parties can negotiate terms on a contractual basis with no minimum or maximum payment structure. Nevertheless, it is important to remember a sales based commission should be sufficient enough to motivate employees and help retain top salespeople whilst remaining in the business’ best financial interests. Should an employee be engaged on a commission-only basis that is permitted by an Award/agreement, it is important to ensure any sales commission agreement satisfies that Award/agreement. Types of Commission Based Jobs Almost every business needs people who can convincingly sell products and services. From cosmetics to new cars and telecommunication, the demand for experienced and enthusiastic salespeople is ongoing. Commission based jobs vary based on the industry and role of the salesperson. Some businesses sell directly to consumers, while others sell to other businesses. These jobs can involve selling face-to-face, cold-calling over the phone, or making sales presentations to high-profile corporate clients. Benefits of Commission Work Employees who are motivated and driven to succeed can reap many benefits from a commission based job. The biggest advantage for an employee on a commission arrangement is being in control of how much you can earn. Whether they already have a base wage or salary, the desire to earn more is a powerful motivator. For employers, it’s easier to monitor the performance of top salespeople and those who are underperforming. Highly motivated salespeople can greatly increase profits for the company and develop long-term relationships with clients who provide repeat business. A tailored and well-drafted commission agreement ensures the employee will only receive the financial benefit subject to high performance. This structure will assist in eliminating the burden of having to overpay less capable employees. For advice on understanding commission pay and your obligations as a business owner, contact our team today.

Wage & Pay

Overpayments

Overpayments are a common issue that many employers in Australia struggle with. Keeping track of staff payments and salaries can be challenging if you do not have access to expert help and support. In this guide, we discuss the overpayment of wages and the process of fixing this error for employers. Overpayments Overpayment of wages can happen when an employer: Mistakenly believes an employee is entitled to the pay. Because of a payroll error. You can fix overpayments if you follow the due process. You can talk to your employee if an overpayment of wages has been made. An arrangement can be made about repayment and noted in writing. Fixing overpayments Getting your money back if you happen to overpay an employee is not always easy. Even if you made a simple clerical error, or misinterpreted an award or agreement, there is a legal process to follow. You can deduct pay if an agreement, award, law, court order, or the Fair Work Commission (FWC) allows it. But if the deductions are for your benefit, they may be unlawful. If your employee then refuses to agree to repay the money, you will have to get a court order. The courts usually say recovery is available if you can show a mistake was made that led to overpayment. Recovery is not possible if the payment was intentionally made, or the employee has already used the money in good faith. Your best option to get the money back is to make an arrangement acceptable to you and your employee where you deduct small amounts from their pay overtime. Always have a clear policy on overpayments in the employment contract and employee handbook, which says employees must report overpayments to their manager immediately. If your employee agrees to repay the money, a written agreement should be made which sets out: Reason for overpayment. Amount of money overpaid. Way repayments will be made. Frequency of repayment (if agreed to repay in instalments) Repayment amount Once the employer has agreed to repay the overpayment, the repayment amount needs to be determined. The repayment amount is not necessarily the overpaid amount. Repayment period If you and the employee become aware of the overpayment within the same financial year, then the employee would repay the net pay. The net pay is the amount that the employee has actually received which does not include any withheld amounts for tax. The employee can decide to pay it in the same or next financial year. If the overpayment is noticed in the following financial year, then the employee would repay the gross pay. The gross pay is the total amount that the employee has been paid, including withheld tax. If the repayment affects the income tax amount for any of the previous 2 years of the employee, then they can request an income tax return. Managing payments and wages Keeping track of payments and wages is crucial as it will help you avoid mistakes such as overpayments. Our team has supported thousands of business owners in Australia with wage information to ensure they correctly pay their employees. For free initial advice on wages and modern awards, contact the expert Peninsula team. This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute as business or legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. It does not take into consideration your specific business, industry or circumstances. You should seek legal or other professional advice regarding matters as they relate to you or your business. To the maximum extent permitted by law, Peninsula Group disclaim all liability for any errors or omissions contained in this information or any failure to update or correct this information. It is your responsibility to assess and verify the accuracy, completeness, and reliability of the information in this article.

Wage & Pay

Overtime rates

Overtime is work performed outside the ordinary hours listed in an award, agreement, or as specified in the employment contract. Ordinary hours are an employee’s regular hours of work, which do not attract overtime rates. Generally, a full-time employee can work a maximum of 38 hours a week unless an employer asks them to work reasonable extra hours. These extra hours will usually be payable as overtime. There may be variations depending on the nature of the job and modern award, which may specify the maximum ordinary hours an employee can work per day or week and times within which the employee can work those ordinary hours. Many awards define overtime as work beyond the maximum number of daily and or weekly hours, outside the daily span of ordinary hours (i.e. 7.00 am – 7.00 pm), or outside the agreed number of hours in the employment agreement. These terms may apply to full-time, part-time, and even casual employees. What are overtime rates? When an employee works overtime, they may be entitled to an overtime rate, which may be higher than the ordinary rate. This will depend upon the Modern Award or Industrial Instrument which covers the employee. As the rate of pay for overtime may differ depending on when it is worked, the applicable rate should also be specified in the respective award, registered agreement, or employment contract. Such payments are intended to compensate employees for the inconvenience of working additional hours and reward them for doing so. Overtime and penalty rates Overtime and Penalty Rates are not the same. Usually,  penalty rates refer to higher rates of pay for working specific hours or days, e.g. weekends, public holidays, after a certain time (6.00 pm) for example. Employers should be familiar with the overtime and penalty rates of their award, or they could face a dispute and be forced to pay back any money owed. When do overtime rates apply? An award, registered agreement, or employment contract will set out the overtime rate and when overtime rates apply, generally when working: Beyond the employee’s ordinary hours of work. Outside the agreed number of hours. Outside the ‘spread’ of ordinary hours. An employer may not have to pay extra for ‘reasonable’ overtime if the employee is paid a higher rate to off-set award entitlements as expressed in their employment contract or registered agreement. Some awards, registered agreements, or employment contracts may allow an employee to take paid time off instead of receiving overtime pay. This is commonly known as ‘time off in lieu’. If employers opt for this approach, it must be established in writing with the employee’s consent and meet any award or agreement requirements. Time off instead of overtime Some awards and registered agreements allow an employee to take paid time off instead of being paid overtime pay. Reasonable overtime The health and safety of an employee must be taken into account when asking them to work overtime. Working beyond a normal 38-hour working week may increase the risk of personal injury, fatigue and work-related stress. It is reasonable to ask an employee to work overtime if the following factors are considered: Whether there is any risk to the health and safety that specifically arises from working extra hours. The employee’s situation including, but not limited to, their family responsibilities. The needs of the workplace. Compensation for having worked the additional hours. Notice given to the employee that they may be required to work overtime. If the employee has previously stated they cannot work overtime. The usual patterns of work in the industry. An employee can only refuse to work overtime if having considered the relevant factors above, the request is unreasonable. When considering whether the employee has received adequate compensation, you can look to any arrangement whereby the employee is paid a higher ordinary rate on the understanding they are required to work some overtime from time to time. Simplify your HR and WHS with Peninsula Learn to manage different types of employees, leave entitlements, and overtime for your business with Peninsula. From an innovative HR software to expert advice from professionals, you get access to the best HR and WHS services in Australia. Contact today to learn how we can help you. This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute as business or legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. It does not take into consideration your specific business, industry or circumstances. You should seek legal or other professional advice regarding matters as they relate to you or your business. To the maximum extent permitted by law, Peninsula Group disclaim all liability for any errors or omissions contained in this information or any failure to update or correct this information. It is your responsibility to assess and verify the accuracy, completeness, and reliability of the information in this article.

Do you have any questions regarding Wage & Pay?